In today’s market, composite decking is frequently hailed as the most cost-effective decking solution. However, are you fully informed about the expenses of the various decking materials available? Merely following trends may not lead to the wisest choice. Let’s dive deeper into this discussion in the article.
There are 3 prevalent decking materials in the market: wood, composite, and PVC. But which one suits you best? In this article, we’ll delve into these decking options to help you make an informed decision based on your budget.
Estimated Costs for Different Decking Materials
When evaluating decks, consider the cost in two dimensions: the initial cost of materials and the long-term cost. Different decking materials age at varying rates, which affects their maintenance costs over time.
Let’s examine both types of costs for composite decking compared to other popular decking materials:
Initial Cost Comparison Between Different Decking Materials
Composite decking is a premium option, requiring a higher initial investment.
Initially, composite deck boards are slightly more expensive than luxury hardwood options like Ipe. Both composite and Ipe decking cost significantly more than basic pressure-treated wood boards. Here are some estimated costs per square foot (note that actual costs can vary based on location and the specific type of board purchased in each category):
Long-Term Cost Comparison Between Different Decking Materials
Composite decking stands out for its low long-term costs. Although the initial investment is higher, the savings over the deck’s lifespan make it a cost-effective choice.
For wood decking (pressure-treated, cedar, or hardwood), regular maintenance is crucial. Sealing and staining should be done at least every few years, ideally annually, to maximize the deck’s longevity.
However, even with diligent maintenance, wood exposed to the elements will weather and degrade over time. Replacing rotted or splintering boards adds unpredictable long-term costs, often arising at inconvenient times.
In contrast, composite decking, like PVC decking, requires no painting or staining. It withstands weathering better, eliminating the need for emergency repairs, as it doesn’t rot, split, or splinter.
Initial Costs vs. Long-Term Costs: Composite vs. Wood vs. PVC Decking
Consider a standard 16 x 20 deck (320 square feet) for a detailed cost comparison:
Estimated Material Costs:
- Wood: $5 per square foot
- Composite: $13 per square foot
- PVC: $ 15 per square foot
Estimated Labor Costs:
- Both materials: $12 per square foot
Estimates exclude fasteners or additional features like framing or railing.
Estimated Maintenance Costs:
- Staining: $3 per square foot
- Sealing: $2 per square foot (including labor and materials)
While composite decking has higher initial material costs, the reduced maintenance and repair expenses over time can make it the more economical choice in the long run.
Pros & Cons of Different Decking Materials
Having evaluated the costs, here’s a detailed overview of the pros and cons of various decking materials to help you make the best decision for your home and deck:
Pressure-Treated Wood
Pros:
- Lowest Cost: Most budget-friendly option available.
- Strength: Durable and strong, providing a sturdy deck.
- Traditional Aesthetic: Offers a classic wood look that many homeowners desire.
Cons:
- High Maintenance: Requires staining or painting every 2-3 years, along with regular repairs.
- Recurring Costs: The ongoing costs of staining and repairs can offset initial savings.
- Limited Styles: Fewer options in terms of look and style compared to other materials.
- Shorter Lifespan: Typically has a shorter lifespan due to natural wear and tear.
- Vulnerability to Elements: Prone to mold, mildew, cracking, splitting, or splintering when exposed to water.
Composite Decking
Pros:
- Durable Capping: Resists mold, mildew, and water damage effectively.
- Low Maintenance: Requires no painting or staining, saving time and effort.
- Long-lasting Appearance: Maintains its look, color, and texture longer than wood.
- Resilient: Does not split, crack, splinter, or rot, ensuring longevity.
Cons:
- Higher Initial Cost: More expensive upfront compared to wood.
- Heat Retention: Can become hot to the touch when exposed to direct sunlight.
PVC Decking
Pros:
- Water Resistance: Completely impervious to water damage, preventing mold, mildew, and rot.
- Pest Resistance: Unaffected by termites and other wood-eating insects.
- Fire Safety: The most fire-safe option available.
- Temperature Regulation: Heats up slower and cools down faster than composite decking, making it more comfortable in direct sunlight.
Cons:
- High Cost: The most expensive decking material on the market.
- Aesthetic Concerns: Older PVC decking options may look artificial, although modern designs have significantly improved.
Each decking material offers distinct advantages and disadvantages. By considering your budget, maintenance preferences, and desired aesthetic, you can select the decking material that best suits your needs and enhances your outdoor living space.
How to Choose the Right Composite Decking?
There are various Wood-Plastic Composite (WPC) decking options available. Here’s how to choose the one that best suits your needs:
1. Ultimate Option: Capped Decking + Solid Profile
If you have a generous budget, capped decking with a solid profile is the ultimate choice. This option offers the best waterproofing, UV resistance, stain resistance, and load-bearing performance. It usually comes with a warranty of at least 25 years, ensuring long-term durability and enjoyment.
2. Cost-Effective Option: Capped Decking + Round Hollow Profile
For a more budget-friendly yet durable choice, consider capped decking with a round hollow profile. This option balances performance and cost, providing good durability and longevity, typically lasting around 20 years. It’s ideal for those looking to save money without compromising too much on quality.
3. Cost-Saving Option: Uncapped Decking + Rectangular-Hollow Profile
The most economical option is uncapped decking with a round-hollow profile. This type uses less composite material to reduce costs. Once installed, the rectangular-hollow design is hidden beneath the deck, maintaining an attractive appearance. It’s perfect for those on a tight budget who still want a functional and appealing deck.
By considering your budget and specific needs, you can select the right composite decking option that offers the best balance of performance, durability, and cost.
Feelingwood is a professional composite decking company offering premium decking solutions and an innovative installation system. It elevates not only your decking boards, but also your installation experience. If you’re seeking the highest quality composite decking solution, reach out to us anytime.
